When the economy shows signs of weakness, Wall Street analysts expect to see what they call a โflight to safety.โ Investors sell stocks and buy bonds or gold. The same phenomenon can sometimes be found in politics. Understanding that George W. Bush was riding high in 2004 after what was perceived as a successful response to the 9/11 attacks, Democrats wagered that Vietnam veteran Senator John Kerry would stand a better chance of victory than the candidate who most excited them, Vermontโs Howard Dean. A popular lapel pin at the time captured the mood, โDated Dean. Married Kerry.โ
The strategy โ to neutralize Bushโs war advantage with Kerryโs war record โ ran into difficulties. There was partisan wrangling over whether Kerry deserved his Purple Hearts and other citations, but most damaging was Kerryโs dubious makeover โ transforming himself from prominent Vietnam War critic into Vietnam War hero. The threads didnโt mesh, and Kerry found himself tangled in contradictions.
Arguably, one story of the Democratic primary race so far has been the competition between two impulses โ the flight to safety versus the urge to splurge.
The first impulse holds Joe Biden aloft. Despite his age, some gobbledygook in debates and on the trail, and his past heresies (from the Democratic primary votersโ perspective) about criminal justice and the Iraq War, Joe Biden has maintained a steady lead. His authorship of the 1994 crime bill, which some believe led to over-incarceration of African Americans, seems not to have dented the enthusiasm of the key constituency in Democratic primaries. He claims a steady 40 percent of African-American support nationally and a whopping 51 percent in South Carolina, according to Monmouth University polling.
Amy Klobuchar is a moderate who tells hard truths to the partyโs progressives. In the January 14 debate, she reminded Bernie Sanders that two-thirds of Senate Democrats donโt support Medicare for All, let alone Republicans. Perhaps thatโs one reason she is among the final six. Klobuchar has struggled to make it into double digits in the polls, though she fulfills many of the desiderata for 2020. Sheโs from the Midwest, which is likely to be key to the Electoral College again. Sheโs neither too young nor too old. She is experienced. She is a solid, realistic gradualist who wouldnโt scare away independents or disaffected Republicans in November. Some might say, well, actually some have said, that sheโs โboring.โ But in an era when politics has become a juvenile insult-fest, dull sounds soothing. Or it might, if safety were your primary goal.
For at least 30 percent of the Democratic electorate, those who currently support Warren or Sanders, swinging for the fences is the mood. They seem to have taken Trumpโs 2016 win as a challenge: If Republicans went wild in 2016, choosing the least reasonable candidate, Democrats deserve their turn in 2020.
Sanders and Warren are โfundamental transformationโ Democrats. Consult Bernieโs website and youโll find plans, or should I say ambitions, to transform everything. It isnโt just Medicare for All. Itโs โhousing for allโ and โcollege for allโ and โfair banking for allโ and โjustice and safety for all.โ Elizabeth Warren has backed away only slightly from her endorsement of Medicare for All. None of the candidates acknowledges that the medical system they decry, when they cite high deductibles and costly prescription drugs, is the one a Democratic president, Barack Obama, passed to solve those very problems. Their approach reminds me of my husbandโs solution to any household problem: โApply force. If that doesnโt work, apply more force.โ
A tiny dose of modesty about vast government solutions to complex problems would go a long way. Perhaps single payer is, as Sanders and Warren claim, the fairest, cheapest, and most efficient way to deliver health care (though policy analysts across the political spectrum spit out their coffee at Sandersโs claims about how much the whole scheme would really cost). But letโs say he and Warren are right. Apparently, a majority of voters in Oregon agrees. Hereโs a crazy idea: Before adopting such a sweeping overhaul of 18 percent of our economy, let Oregon experiment with it and letโs see in five years how it worked out.
There is one more safety candidate waiting in the wings. Mike Bloomberg is skipping the early contests but hiring and advertising now. Has this been tried before? Yes, another former New York mayor, Rudy Giuliani, skipped Iowa and New Hampshire in 2008. Of course, Giuliani (to his great regret) didnโt sit atop a $58 billion fortune.
All eyes are on Biden, Sanders, Warren, and Buttigieg now, but primaries bring surprises.
COPYRIGHT 2020 CREATORS.COM
From left: Activist Tom Steyer, Senator Elizabeth Warren, former vice president Joe Biden, Senator Bernie Sanders, South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg, and Senator Amy Klobuchar on stage for the Democratic primary debate at Drake University in Des Moines, Iowa, January 14, 2020.
Shannon Stapleton/Reuters
































Comments