Bench Memos

Picking Judges to Be Federal Judges

There are good magistrates and state judges who have been elevated to federal judgeships. But the presumption tends to be that they’re not ideal picks.

Share this story

Michał Chodyra/Getty Images

One of the biggest changes in judicial nominations over the last 20 years is that sitting judges are more rarely picked to be federal judges. By that I mean for many years, one of the surer paths to a federal judgeship was to be a state judge, a magistrate judge, or district court judge (for the court of appeals). That largely stopped in the first Trump administration, a trend that continued in the Biden administration. From what we have seen so far, it is likely to continue.

Some of this has to do with the changing dynamics of the confirmation process. During the Bush and early Obama years, when 60 votes were necessary to advance a judicial nominee, it was rhetorically powerful to say, “He has a judicial track record. We know his temperament and his fairness.” Even after the “nuclear option,” this was Obama’s preferred trick to coax a Republican Senate to confirm his judges. At least half the judges confirmed in the 113th Congress had judicial experience.

Michael A. Fragoso

About the Author

Michael A. Fragoso

Michael A. Fragoso is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He previously served as chief counsel to Senator Mitch McConnell and chief counsel for judicial nominations and constitutional law on the Senate Judiciary Committee. He clerked for Judge Sykes from 2014 to 2015.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement