Bench Memos

The Cost of Inaction in Maine

Share this story

A general view of Maine State House in Augusta, Maine, January 3, 2024.

Lauren Owens Lambert/Reuters

The people of Maine’s 90th district are currently without representation in their House of Representatives. This is because their representative, Laurel Libby, has been censured by the body for speaking out against trans high school athletics, and in Maine this means she can be prohibited from speaking or voting in the legislature until she apologizes. This outrage is in litigation, but no resolution seems to be forthcoming.

It’s an outrage because Representative Libby was duly elected and yet can’t do her job. She hasn’t been, say, expelled for breaking the rules of the body. Instead she’s being coerced into changing her views. It thus is an affront to her free speech rights and the rights of her constituents to representation.

Michael A. Fragoso

About the Author

Michael A. Fragoso

Michael A. Fragoso is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. and a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He previously served as chief counsel to Senator Mitch McConnell and chief counsel for judicial nominations and constitutional law on the Senate Judiciary Committee. He clerked for Judge Sykes from 2014 to 2015.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement