Things continue to deteriorate in the trial of Kyle Rittenhouse, the 18-year old who shot and killed two men and wounded another during a riot over the police shooting of Jacob Blake in Kenosha, Wis., in summer 2020. (Rittenhouse was 17 at the time.) As Robert VerBruggen wrote yesterday:
The prosecutionโs own witnesses kept saying things that helped the defense. Richie McGinnis, a Daily Caller videographer, testified that the first person Rittenhouse shot had chased him and lunged for his weapon. (When a prosecutor tried to cast doubt on whether McGinnis could know what the guy was trying to do, he memorably replied, โUh, well, he said โ[f***] you,โ and then he reached for the weapon.โ) Gaige Grosskreutz, the armed man Rittenhouse shot in the bicep, admitted that Rittenhouse had not fired when he had his hands up, and shot only when Grosskreutzโs own gun was pointed at Rittenhouse.
On top of the inconsistencies that VerBruggen describes, another revelation that has surfaced during the trial is that Grosskreutz originally lied to police about having a gun at all. As CNN writes, โGrosskreutz acknowledged he incorrectly told police last year that his firearm had fallen out of his pants that night and did not admit that he had a weapon at the time.โ Grosskreutz maintains that the omission was not โpurposeful,โ and that it was because he โhad just gone through one of the most traumatic experiencesโ of his life, โboth emotionally and physically,โ as well as being on pain medication from a recent surgery.
Either way, the prosecutionโs path to conviction looks more difficult than it did going into the trial. And things got even worse earlier today when the judge laid into a very chastened-looking prosecutor: โI was astonished when you began his examination by commenting on the defendantโs post-arrest silence,โ he said, raising his voice in visible anger. โThatโs basic law. Itโs been basic law in this country for 40 years, 50 years.โ
Of course, thereโs a lot of trial left, and there may yet be more important facts that are brought to bear. To be clear, Kyle Rittenhouseโs decision to bring an assault rifle to a violent riot was foolish. But as Isaac Schorr tweeted earlier today, โBeing somewhere you probably shouldnโt be is not a crime.โ And using a firearm to defend oneself is what the Second Amendment is for. If the prosecution canโt prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Rittenhouse was guilty of more than being somewhere he shouldnโt have been โ and was engaging in more than self-defense โ they might be in serious trouble.







Comments
On โMore Trouble for the Kyle Rittenhouse Prosecutionโ