When are charitable works acts of faith? The Supreme Court had to decide that question this morning in Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor & Industry Review Commission. The decision provided the third of the big, unanimous conservative wins delivered by the Court today, and it, too, was written by one of the Courtโs three liberals, Justice Sonia Sotomayor.
Religious organizations and institutions have long played an important role in American communities. In recognition of that, federal and state laws can and do provide some exceptions for those groups from generally applicable laws. Thereโs a tension between this and the First Amendment rules that religious groups canโt be barred from equal participation in secular benefits and canโt be singled out for discriminatory punishment, but the benefits specific to religious groups usually come in the form of tax exemptions and similar efforts to disentangle government from involvement in how religions are run. Thus, for example, the Court has recognized a fairly narrow โministerial exceptionโ under which employment and other laws cannot interfere with a religious groupโs choice of ministers. The core personnel decisions of a church are free from government interference, even if the same decisions are pervasively regulated in secular institutions, because we donโt want the government running the churches.






Comments