The Corner
PlusMedia

Supreme Court Silly Season at Politico, Part One

Share this story

Members of the media set up their work area outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C., February 8, 2024.

Amanda Andrade-Rhoades/Reuters

We are heading into the spring home stretch for the Supreme Court, which has (depending upon how you count them) 49 cases left on its docket to decide in the next three months. That works out to an average of 3.7 decisions a week between Monday and the end of June, on a broad array of issues including free speech, social media, the administrative state, abortion, gun rights, Trump prosecutions and presidential immunity, redistricting, and constitutional limits on taxation. That means we get a predictable rise in efforts by the Left and its media wing to alternately smear the justices, spin conspiracy theories about the conservative legal movement, and gin up implausible legal theories to get the Left what it wants. The reverent coverage of the Christine Blasey Ford book tour is one example of that.

Politico dove face-first into the shallow end of this pool with a pair of articles over the past week. First up was Heidi Przybyla on “What happens when an AG dares to investigate Leonard Leo’s network.” Przybyla has been a persistently overwrought and misleading voice in the chorus attacking the conservative judges, the conservative legal movement, and Leo personally. Just since December 2022, that has included a vague hit piece implying that Leo took advantage of the Federalist Society by poaching its donors, an illogical hit job on Justice Neil Gorsuch over the sale of a house, a misleading and conspiratorial attack on Supreme Court amicus briefs that overstated Leo’s role, a non sequitur about Leo having helped Kellyanne Conway sell her polling company seven years ago, and — most publicly — a bizarrely overwritten and borderline libelous attack on “Christian nationalism” that mislabels the players and confuses the concept with natural law and natural rights, a confusion that Przybyla made explicit in an ill-considered MSNBC interview denouncing the radical notion that our rights are something we are endowed with by our Creator. (Przybyla was previously at NBC News, where she produced shoddy and misleading Covid reporting).

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

Advertisement

Advertisement