The Corner

The Garland DOJ’s Wild Transgender Lawsuit against Tennessee

Share this story

Attorney General Merrick Garland announces that he is appointing former U.S. Attorney Robert Hur as a special counsel to investigate President Joe Biden’s handling of classified documents at the Justice Department in Washington, D.C., January 12, 2023.

Leah Millis/Reuters

For the latest episode in Merrick Garland turning the United States Department of Justice into a left-wing blog that continually attacks democracy in the states, consider its complaint filed Wednesday by the DOJ in the Middle District of Tennessee, joining a lawsuit against Tennessee’s law prohibiting the use of puberty blockers and other transgender medical procedures on minors. S.B. 1, the Tennessee law, is derived from two basic premises. One, like the bans in at least 22 states on “gay conversion therapy,” it reflects the state legislature’s determination that what proponents describe in Orwellian terms as “gender-affirming care” is dangerous quackery that the state can appropriately regulate or ban. Two, children and teenagers are legally incapable of consenting to this form of irrevocable change to their bodies, and, like the bans on female genital mutilation in 27 states, it is a sufficiently abusive practice that the legislature can step in to protect kids from having it foisted on them by adults, including their parents. There is a strong presumption in favor of letting parents make health decisions for their children, but it is not an unlimited license to conduct irreversible medical experiments on them — and a democratic system of government allows different states to make different choices about where to draw that line. Indeed, some states have passed laws that, in the same bill, ban gay conversion therapy while encouraging gender-transition treatments.

The DOJ lawsuit — filed, of course, by the Civil Rights Division under Kristen Clarke — argues that S.B. 1 violates the Equal Protection clause of the 14th Amendment. The suit has three separate problems.

Dan McLaughlin

About the Author

Dan McLaughlin

Dan McLaughlin is a senior writer at National Review Online and a fellow at National Review Institute.

Comments

On “The Garland DOJ’s Wild Transgender Lawsuit against Tennessee”

Advertisement

Advertisement