Isaac Schorr here, filling in for Jim Geraghty; buckle up, because youโve caught me in some kind of mood.
There is no menu: Youโre home, Dadโs a terrible cook, all thatโs in the fridge are frozen vegetables โ and heโs doing the best he can.
The โWeโre Just Plain Evilโ Blueprint
I canโt foresee myself ever casting a vote for a Democrat because to me, there are virtually no redeeming qualities to the institutional Democratic Party.
It has a bottomless appetite for spending money it doesnโt presently have but intends on taking from me. It has an intolerable tolerance for crime, homelessness, drug use, and disorder. It has no care for the Constitution, and no confidence in the righteousness of Americaโs position vis-ร -vis those of its geopolitical and ideological adversaries. It supports experimental treatments on and the castration of children suffering from gender dysphoria. It supports elective abortions on-demand until a child is born.
But Democrats mostly contain their flaws to misbegotten policies that theyโre able to paint in an appealing-enough light on the campaign trail.
They couch their support for violent, unthinkable late-term abortions in the reasonable-sounding notion that an unplanned pregnancy presents a woman with a tough decision that should be kept between her and her doctor, or hide behind โsupport for Roe v. Wade.โ They say that if we donโt provide children with the euphemistic โgender-affirming careโ they seek, theyโll kill themselves. They screech about the separation of church and state. They know that in the cities where crime is most pronounced, theyโre mostly protected by their complete dominance of local politics and government, and when things get really bad there, they pay lip service to policies aimed at cleaning up the streets.
The GOP, meanwhile, is increasingly embracing the approach of the Republican Party of The Simpsons:

Too many Republican candidates present themselves as โ and voters throw their support behind โ the proudly malicious, whose primary virtue is their vice. Iโm making the furthest thing from a novel point by holding up Donald Trump as the preeminent example of this phenomenon, but my goodness, what an example!
It was less than two years ago that Trump egged on a mob that stormed the Capitol chanting about hanging his own vice president on the basis of a lie he was peddling. Three weeks ago, he urged โU.S. Jewsโ to โget their act together.โ On Monday, Election Day Eve, he called Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi โan animalโ just a little over a week after her 82-year-old husband underwent brain surgery for injuries sustained while fending off an attacker with intentions to break the Speakerโs kneecaps. How do you explain away any of this?
And Jolters, you may recognize that this is a non-exhaustive list.
Moreover, his unrestrained id has trickled down into the partyโs candidates. Arizonaโs Kari Lake praises do-no-gooders such as Wendy Rogers and tells โMcCain Republicansโ โ a reference to the late John McCain, who endured being bayoneted in the foot and stomach, having his arm broken, ribs cracked, and shoulder shattered as a prisoner of the North Vietnamese โ to โget the hellโ away from her rallies. J. D. Vance boasts that he doesnโt โreally care what happens to Ukraine one way or another.โ Doug Mastriano attended the rally that preceded the January 6 Capitol riot. Blake Masters cut an ad during which he proudly pronounced that โTrump won in 2020.โ Mehmet Oz used his status and medical expertise to make money selling magic beans. Herschel Walker . . . well, God only knows what Herschel Walker has done.
However much Trump โ who endorsed each of these candidates during their primary contests โ may smile upon this lot, most Americans are revolted by those who say, do, and revel in revolting things. And the only people who donโt recognize Trump and his croniesโ behavior as revolting are political addicts who have their unrestrained id fed by low-knowledge, high-energy media personalities such as Benny Johnson, who on Election Day declared that, โWhat the Republican electorate wants is a strong executive who utilizes and wields power over his enemies. And then destroys his enemies and makes them grovel, makes molten salty tears flow from their faces.โ
People whose frustrations with the results โ and reasonably some of the processes around โ the 2020 election quickly gave way to a certainty that it was stolen from them, a certainty thatโs been reinforced by true believers and line walkers (โit wasnโt stolen, it was RIGGED!โ) alike. People for whom time and an affinity for the results of the Trump administrationโs policies desensitized them to the obvious, exhausting malice of the administrationโs namesake. People who are assured by the commentators they mistakenly trust that whatโs really holding the GOP back is the presence of Dan Crenshaw and Ben Sasse in Congress. People who have concluded that because the media will take every opportunity to smear conservatives, no real conservative offense matters.
Now, some of Trumpโs candidates have or may ultimately prevail. But if Tuesday proved nothing else, itโs that general-election voters are sensitive to the malice that some amount of the GOP electorate seemingly no longer is, and that theyโre willing to respond to it by punishing the Republican Party collectively for its indulgence. How else do you explain the Democratsโ ability to win in purple and even red (Kansas!) states while saddled with a wildly unpopular president, mass dissatisfaction with the economy, and fiascoes such as the Biden administrationโs surrender to the Taliban?
So when a candidate offers you the โmolten salty tearsโ of his opponents, ask whether voters might want something that tastes better. And when youโre reading or watching conservative media that only ever pushes you toward a single conclusion โ that you are righteous and your enemies should be made to endure the worst โ ask yourself if theyโre not sending you down a road that ends in disappointment.
Malice can win under the right circumstances, namely, when facing down more malice (see: 2016), but generally, itโs a losing ingredient. It need not be included to deliver sweeping conservative electoral and policy victories (see: Ron DeSantis this year, Glenn Youngkin last year).
While Democrats may not have earned their overperformance this year, Republicans richly deserved their underperformance. If they donโt relearn to recoil at unbridled malevolence โ and instead follow the lead of Vance, House Republican Conference chairwoman Elise Stefanik, and others by insisting that Trump and the inevitable baggage that comes with him are not only the past, but the future of the GOP โ theyโll deserve the string of disappointments that come.
ADDENDUM: Be sure to read Dominic Pinoโs article on the debt of gratitude Republicans owe their candidate for governor in New York. Lee Zeldin turned in quite the performance:
In what turned out to be a less successful Republican House performance than expected nationwide, New Yorkโs Republican congressional candidates did well. In the likely narrow Republican House majority that will result when the dust settles, itโs possible that New York will have made the difference between GOP control and another term as speaker for Nancy Pelosi. For that, we have Lee Zeldin to thank.







Comments
On โVoting for Vice Has Its Downsidesโ